Q&As
Be in to win
QI am in my late 50s and do not currently have KiwiSaver. After returning to New Zealand from overseas, I had other financial priorities.
I then spent several years funding nearly $100,000 of my own cancer treatment. To do this, I kept my savings in bank investments that I could access whenever needed.
Thankfully, I am now through treatment, back in full-time work, and able to plan for the future. Friends often tell me I am missing out by not joining KiwiSaver, but my experience has made me value having control over and access to my money.
My question: if KiwiSaver investment earnings are taxed each year, are those earnings available to withdraw at that time, or are they automatically added back into the fund and remain subject to KiwiSaver withdrawal restrictions?
I feel I may be missing something, but I struggle with the idea of paying tax on gains that I cannot access.
AKiwiSaver investment earnings — interest, dividends, rent and gains made by the funds you invest in — are not available to withdraw. They stay in your account, compounding over the years and growing your balance by much more than just the contributions you make.
When you turn 65, you’ll get access to the returns with bells on!
Still, I understand your reluctance to tie up money in KiwiSaver. It’s always good to keep some money accessible — while noting that it’s possible to make early withdrawals from KiwiSaver if you are in financial hardship.
But your friends are right — you miss out lots by not taking part in KiwiSaver.
It sounds as if you are an employee. That means for every dollar you put into KiwiSaver, your employer puts in nearly a dollar. The “nearly” is because employer contributions are taxed. But they still greatly boost your balance. On top of that, you get an annual government contribution of 25 cents for every dollar you put in, up to $261 if you put in $1,043 or more.
Together, the employer and government contributions roughly double your money going into KiwiSaver. That’s a big deal. Twice the money going in means twice as much at retirement. If you would have saved $100,000 out of KiwiSaver, you’ll save $200,000 within the scheme.
When I say “roughly double”, the effect is strongest for those on lower incomes, because of the cap on government contributions. But still, someone earning $200,000 will find their employee contributions are multiplied by 1.7. Their $100,000 outside KiwiSaver becomes $170,000. See our table.
| Income | From you (employees: 3.5% of pay) | From employer (3.5% taxed) | From government | Total inputs | How much your $$$ is multiplied |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $20,000 | $700 | $578 | $175 | $1,453 | 2.08 times |
| $40,000 | $1,400 | $1,155 | $261 | $2,816 | 2.01 times |
| $60,000 | $2,100 | $1,733 | $261 | $4,094 | 1.95 times |
| $100,000 | $3,500 | $2,345 | $261 | $6,106 | 1.74 times |
| $200,000 | $7,000 | $4,690 | Zero | $11,950 | 1.71 times |
| Non-employees | $1,043 | Zero | $261 | $1,304 | 1.25 times |
If you are not an employee, your savings will still grow faster in KiwiSaver, as the table shows.
Having said that, don’t overdo KiwiSaver. Read on.
P.S. it’s not good you had to spend so much on your cancer treatment. But that’s another story.
Access matters
QI am a single parent, closer to retirement than not, with a mortgage and a teenager finishing secondary school. I became unemployed just over a year ago and have been using savings to meet the shortfall.
Recently I applied for a significant financial hardship KiwiSaver withdrawal. I qualified, but I still have accessible savings and have been advised to use these until I have approximately $2,000 left before reapplying.
Once my child leaves at year-end, I plan to relocate with better employment opportunities and rent my home. Depleting my capital risks removing my ability to get myself out of hardship.
Had I understood this potential scenario earlier, I would have structured my retirement investment differently.
Should people approaching retirement, particularly those with mortgages, be encouraged to consider not just retirement savings but liquidity — and the consequences of having too much of their wealth locked inside KiwiSaver?
AYou — and too many others — are in an unenviable situation. But it’s great that you have a sound plan to improve things.
As many are finding out, it’s not easy to withdraw your KiwiSaver money before you turn 65. And generally that’s good. Otherwise, some people would dip into their balances quite often, and retire with little. But there are many cases — including yours — when the rules seem harsh.
So yes, it’s a good idea if everyone puts into KiwiSaver only enough to get the maximum employer contributions. Put savings beyond that somewhere that is quickly accessible.
A couple of notes:
- The accessible savings don’t have to be in a bank account or term deposits. You could use a non-KiwiSaver cash fund.
- For anyone who is a big spender, who might blow your non-KiwiSaver savings on treats, the inaccessibility of KiwiSaver money might be a plus if you want to have plenty to spend in retirement.
All the best with your move.
How to change Super?
QMany people argue that they’ve paid tax all their lives so they deserve to receive NZ Superannuation. But aren’t we paying our taxes to keep healthcare, schools and other essential infrastructure running? Superannuation in its current form is a luxury that New Zealand can no longer afford.
Much is said about raising the age. It’s easy enough to work late into your sixties in an office with heating/aircon and during daylight hours. It’s not so easy to work 12-hour night shifts (nurses, caregivers, emergency services and others) plus manual workers.
Also, keeping people working later isn’t going to help youth unemployment, with jobs not becoming available. Granted, many people in their late 60s hold senior roles, unsuitable for inexperienced youth. But if they retire, everyone can move up a rung, leaving space at the bottom for people starting out.
How about anyone earning $200,000 doesn’t receive Superannuation. If you earn $150,000 you get 75% of Super, $100,000 50%, down to $50,000 where you receive the full superannuation. Anyone earning $200,000 has likely earned well for some years and has been able to save, unlike those earning minimum wage. I’d be interested in your thoughts.
AYou’re right that NZ Super is not funded from taxes paid over the years, but from current taxes. And there are many calls for payments to be reduced.
As you say, raising the Super starting age from 65 could bring problems, but how about means testing, so wealthier people get less?
Many people don’t realise that this already happens to some extent, as NZ Super is taxed. This means:
- If you’re single, your fortnightly payment ranges from $1,110 if you have little or no other income down to $790 if you’re in the top 39% tax bracket.
- If you have a partner, the payment ranges from $854 each down to $601 each.
The high earners get nearly 30% less.
But you’re proposing a more radical difference. And I have some sympathy with the idea. Trouble is, it would be easy to wriggle around.
If we based someone’s Super on their income in the last year or few years, it would pay people to deliberately switch to working part-time in the last few years.
And what about someone who was unemployed right before they reached 65, but had earned heaps before that? Or someone who was self-employed with a really up-and-down income? Whatever system we had, it would unfairly penalise some, and others would rip it off.
Another approach would be to base Super payments on people’s wealth, rather than their income. But that really invites trouble. If house prices or share prices are high when someone retires, they would get less Super than their friend, who owns similar assets but retires when markets have slumped.
Alternatively, we could assess everyone’s wealth each year. But what an administrative nightmare that would be.
Then there would be people who give their family home to their children, on condition that the oldies live in it until they die. That would make their wealth low so they get lots of Super. Or they could park their investments in another country, where it’s impossible for the government to find them.
Meanwhile, the taxpayer is spending vast amounts on paying officials to run all this, including trying to catch the cheats.
NZ Super is regarded by experts as one of the best government retirement income systems in the world, largely because it is simple, universal and cheap to run. We mess with that at our peril.
One more point. Youth unemployment is indeed a worry, but I don’t think changing the age Super starts would make much difference. It’s not as simple as: We have a finite number of jobs, so if one person holds a job, another person misses out.
Think of an uninhabited island. Then 1,000 people arrive and settle there. After a while, perhaps 900 of them will have occupations — from producing goods and services to taking care of others to attending school. There will also be, say, 100 people dependent on others for their care.
Then more people come to the island. Are there still just 900 jobs? No. As the economy expands, so do the jobs. There are more people needing goods and services and more people to take care of. The more people who work, the more jobs there are.
Let’s look at the individual level. If someone continues to work from, say, age 65 to 70, the fact they are working and not retired will probably create roughly one more job for a young person.
How come? The working person will earn an income, and probably spend much of it. They are likely to buy more clothes, eat out more and spend more on transport than if they had retired. They’re also more likely to hire others to clean their house, mow their lawn, care for their garden, deliver fast food and in many other ways pay someone to make life easier because they have less free time than their retired friends.
They create a bit of a job here, a bit of a job there. In total, it’s probably about one whole job.
Testing risk tolerance
QI refer to the mid-30’s female correspondent in your last column who has invested in managed funds, sees a loss in value and states, “This is causing me a lot of anxiety and fear that I will lose a lot of money.”
I accept the wisdom that time in the market is always important over timing. However, as a former investment adviser and sharebroker, I had a simple test to check clients’ risk tolerance and to then structure their investments accordingly.
I spoke of the New Zealand sharemarket dropping 40% in 1990 and then asked the client:
“If the current value of your share investments dropped 40%:
- Would you be able to continue to live the lifestyle you want to now or in the future? (Financial lifestyle risk)
- Would you be able to sleep at night?” (Psychological risk)
If they said “No” to either question, the portfolio exposure to higher-risk investments would be reduced until they said “Yes” to both questions.
I suggest your correspondent’s response to the second question is clearly “No”, indicating strong psychological discomfort, thereby supporting an immediate reduction in the riskier investments.
AFair point. I perhaps didn’t take her discomfort sufficiently into account.
But she did say she also has a KiwiSaver investment, whose value has fluctuated, but it “hasn’t caused me the anxiety my new investments have.” I was hoping to spread that acceptance of volatility to her newer investments.
In any case, your questions are good for any investor. Thanks.
Staying the course
QI wanted to offer reassurance to the single mid-30s woman who wrote about anxiety when seeing investment values dip shortly after investing.
At age 32 my wife and I made a first investment in equities on September 10, 2001. Everyone knows what happened the next day. I’d like to say I had an iron constitution, but I did try to see if I could get the money back before it was invested. But no! The stock market went down by more than 10% in just a few days.
We held the course and still have that same money in those Vanguard index funds (we were living in Australia at the time). They are worth roughly six times as much now. So to your correspondent I say, “I hear you, but relax and go to the beach. It will be alright.”
AGosh, you went through an extreme example of a downturn soon after investing. But look at you now!
Personal philosophy
QLast time you wrote, “the type of governance and country I would like for our grandchildren is one that shows compassion and gives support to people whose ‘progress in life’ is not as easy as yours and mine.”
There you have it — the personal philosophy that underpins your commentary and makes it such a great read.
AThank you so much.
No paywalls or ads — just generous people like you. All Kiwis deserve accurate, unbiased financial guidance. So let’s keep it free. Can you help? Every bit makes a difference.
Mary Holm, ONZM, is a freelance journalist, a seminar presenter and a bestselling author on personal finance. She is a former director of the Financial Markets Authority, the Banking Ombudsman Scheme and Financial Services Complaints Ltd. Mary’s advice is of a general nature, and she is not responsible for any loss that any reader may suffer from following it. Send questions to [email protected]. Letters should not exceed 200 words. We won’t publish your name. Please provide a (preferably daytime) phone number. Unfortunately, Mary cannot answer all questions, correspond directly with readers, or give financial advice.